Monday, December 8, 2014

Murky Waters: WWF Sustainable Salmon Certification




Marine Harvest Salmon Farms
John Fredriksen  is the principal owner of Marine Harvest and also a financial investor.  A third of all commercial salmon production worldwide is in the hands of Fredriksen. With an estimated private fortune of 13.5 billion dollars, the “salmon king” is one of the richest men on the planet. Marine Harvest dumps 100 million salmon a year onto the global market.

The WWF entered into a partnership deal with Marine Harvest in order to promote aquaculture as a sustainable food resource that can increase the world’s food supply.  It sounds like a wonderful idea and aquaculture, properly managed, can indeed be a clean method of producing fish in large quantities.  However, when they are not properly managed, problems ensue.

Be aware that there is a big difference in Marine Harvest’s Norwegian aquafarms and their fish farms in other parts of the world like Chile and India.  The water in their Norwegian aquafarms is much cleaner; hygiene regulations are adhered to and state supervision is strict. Violators of environmental laws lose their licensing and Norway operators must reapply annually for each and every individual farm in a production area. However, Marine Harvest gets its Chilean licenses at a rock bottom price -- 150 dollars a year for one hectare of sea area. And then there are the low wages in Chile: about ten percent of the labor costs of Norway.  This makes Chile ripe for exploitation and Marine Harvest picked it for just that reason.

When the individual farms are too close together and too many salmon are crammed into each cage (200,000+), infectious disease, namely ISA – Infectious Salmon Anemia, can spread throughout the entire fish farm.  In poorly regulated and managed farms, these dead fish are used in fish meal production that will be used to feed living fish.  Since the salmon are heavily insured – MH reaps profit on fish that die as well as the fish meal that is produced.

Farm-bred salmon are often referred to as “swimming pharmacies.”  Outside of Europe, where there are laws about aquaculture management, 800 times the amount of antibiotics are often used.  These are the same antibiotics used to treat humans.  Marine Harvest can add as much antibiotic to a single feed farm as used by the entire Norwegian salmon industry in a year!  Even eggs are treated with carcinogenic containing substances like crystal violet and malachite green.  Feeding cages are routinely painted with “protective” agents that contain heavy metals.

Salmon need large amounts of animal protein. Feed concentrate is dumped into the cages by the ton and is made mainly of fishmeal and fish oil.  4-6 kilos of wild fish are killed to make meal that produces one kilo of salmon.  More than half of the world’s fish catch goes to making feed concentrate for salmon and other animals.  Since the farm bred salmon eat more animal protein than they produce, how can that be sustainable?  Since they eat diseased fish and are doused in antibiotics, how can that be healthy?

Nelson Estrada, president of a Chilean fishing union tells reporters: 

“The industry has bought up most of the fishing licenses. Our entire catch goes to the feed industry – although anchovies are very healthy and high in protein. It’s criminal. This industry disgusts me, but I have to support my family, that’s why I work for them.”

“We’re nothing but slaves of the transnational industry; there are no independent fishermen left in Chile.”

Holds on board ships contain multi-ton mountains of glistening little anchovy bodies. “I’m ashamed of this here: these fish are tiny; they haven’t even reached sexual maturity. We’re plundering the stocks before they can even reproduce. There’ll be nothing left for future generations.”  As small salmon farms in Chile are unable to compete with the Marine Harvest giant, they go broke – and Marine Harvest buys them all. 

 Experiments are being made to increase the vegetable protein in feeds – using soy -- genetically engineered, roundup ready soy that is the product of Monsanto.  This would provide cheaper feed for the salmon producers looking to cut even more costs.  Thus, quality is sacrificed for profit at the expense of people’s lives, a healthy planet and eco-diversity.

Salmon, including genetically engineered salmon, often escape their cages and since they are predators, they eat everything in the local waters.  Diseased salmon spread ISA to wild populations. The escapees also breed with the wild salmon and this wreaks havoc on wild fish populations while genetic diversity is lost in the process.

The seabeds beneath the salmon cages are polluted with junk, rotten feed, salmon feces and dead marine life floating in the murky water.  The industry uses the see as a garbage dump and nothing can live in it.  The WWF does nothing to stop it either.

The salmon industry has also begun to deplete the ocean of its mainstay – krill.  These tiny crabs are food for countless marine animals.  Damn the consequences to the ocean’s wildlife – selling $almon is all that matters to them. 

Marine Harvest and the Human Factor

Chile had an abundant resource of fish and shellfish.  If people were employed in the traditional fishing industry rather than in salmon farming, they would live with much more dignity and produce a higher quality product.  People and the natural environment would thrive under proper stewardship.  However, corporate growth and greed in the food industry is destroying our planet.   Marine Harvest and other giant food industries focus on one part of the ecosystem – salmon, or soybeans or whatever rakes in the big money – all at the expense of people, the earth and its flora and fauna.

WWF admits to taking money from Marine Harvest.  They claim that the salmon industry will benefit Chile’s coastal inhabitants by creating paying jobs.  The salmon industry has not benefited the coastal inhabitants one iota.

Imagine working in the stench of dead and rotting salmon without protective clothing or face masks.  The dead salmon are packed in sacks in left until a ship can collect them so this working environment is common.

Silos surround the fish farms.  They act as oxygen compressors to give artificial respiration to the sea and salmon. The overcrowded salmon suffocate without enough oxygen. About 6,000 Chilean salmon divers must chase away sea lions looking for a meal.  Those sea lions can be very territorial over a possible meal. 

The divers use a garden hose type apparatus (not real scuba diving equipment) to perform this work.  The tubes are often damaged and torn.  Divers can get tangled up in nets and are unable to resurface.  Regulations state they can only dive to 20 feet, but the company forces them to dive to 40 feet. Each salmon farm must have a decompression chamber within a radius of 500 meters but usually they don’t exist or are defective.  Dead divers cost the company little and they do die on the job on a regular basis. 

No matter what Marine Harvest does, the justice system protects perpetrators, not victims.  And so does the WWF.

WWF Sustainability Certification

The global “Aquaculture Dialogue” program  was another project of the WWF.  The certification would greenwash the ugly truth of poorly run $almon farms.  Companies must pay for this certification so there is money to be made by those who issue the certificates.

Certification Standards of the MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) and ASC (Aquaculture Stewardship Council) exclude genetically modified salmon and requires disclosure of the use of any transgenic GMO material used in feed.   However, GE modified salmon will likely obtain approval and green certification at some time.  

In 2013 a US biotech company, Aquabounty, produced the first genetically engineered salmon.  The GM salmon eggs are now mass produced and marketed.  Marine Harvest claimed it would not consider farming GE salmon.  However, how could such a corporation resist the new “frankenfish” that grow twice as fast as the old farm-bred salmon?  Don’t  trust them to turn away the opportunity for twice the profits for 2x the amount of salmon flesh.

According to the WWF website: “Always ask for sustainably sourced salmon. Even if it isn't available, demand for sustainable seafood will drive fisheries and retailers towards a sustainable future. Look for MSC (Marine Stewardship Council) certification on salmon and salmon products.”

One Last Note
We have touched briefly on  the salmon industry but there is more WWF-style “sustainability” in Chile. Chile’s forests have been turned into pulp lumber operations which bear the FSC “eco-label”. The Forest Stewardship Council certification was also co-founded by the WWF.  Destruction of animal habitat for profit was supported by them.  No people can live on the corporate lands, of course. Those that work for the pulp mills, work in sub-standard conditions.  It’s the same old story worldwide.

References and Further Reading


Certification: Watch out for the 'Abominable Salmon Council' - bringing 'responsible' farmed salmon to a supermarket near you soon!   The Global Alliance against Sustainable Aquaculture.   


Greenpeace Seafood Sustainability Report. Carting Away the Oceans. (2013)
 
PandaLeaks: The Dark Side of the WWF.   (Wilfried Huismann)

Some WWF Corporate benefactors:

MSC and ASC accredited Salmon Producers:



Certified Chain of Custody Suppliers are also listed in this section

(this is not the most user friendly site - but the information is there)

No comments: